Railway

Railway: Pentest vs Automated Scan

Pentests cost $5k-$50k+ and take weeks. For Railway apps, automated scanning catches the same vulnerabilities instantly. Here's how to decide.

Scan Free — See What a Pentest Would Find

No signup required. Results in 5 minutes.

$10k+
Avg Pentest Cost
2-4 wks
Pentest Timeline
Free
VAS Core Scan
5 min
Scan Time

Pentest vs Automated Scan

Category
Penetration Test
VAS Scan
Winner
Cost
$5,000 - $50,000+
Free (VAS Core) to $99/mo (Pro)
Scan
Time to Results
2-4 weeks
5 minutes
Scan
Common Vulnerabilities
Finds all standard issues
Finds all standard issues
Tie
Business Logic Flaws
Excellent (human analysis)
Limited
Pentest
Continuous Monitoring
Point-in-time only
Scan after every deploy
Scan
Compliance Reports
Detailed attestation
Basic compliance mapping
Pentest
Coverage Depth
Deep, manual exploration
Systematic, pattern-based
Pentest
False Positives
Very low (human verified)
Low (tuned for vibe-coded apps)
Pentest
Scalability
Expensive to repeat
Unlimited scans
Scan

When You Need a Pentest

  • You're handling highly sensitive data (healthcare, finance)
  • You have regulatory compliance requirements (SOC 2, PCI-DSS)
  • You have complex custom business logic
  • You're about to raise significant funding
  • You need a formal security attestation
  • Your app has been breached and you need forensics

When Automated Scanning Works

  • You're building an MVP or early-stage product
  • You want immediate security feedback
  • You need to scan after every deployment
  • Your budget is limited
  • You're using standard tech stacks (Supabase, Firebase)
  • You want to fix obvious issues before a pentest

Railway Security Reality

Railway applications have predictable security patterns. The most common vulnerabilities—exposed secrets, missing access controls, weak authentication—are well-documented and consistently detected by automated scanners. A pentest will find these same issues, but at a much higher cost.

Common Railway Vulnerabilities (Caught by Both)

  • Hardcoded API keys and secrets
  • Missing database access controls
  • Weak authentication configuration
  • Missing security headers
  • Insecure session management

A $15,000 pentest finds these. VAS finds them in 5 minutes for free.

The Verdict

For most Railway applications, start with automated scanning. It's free, instant, and catches the vulnerabilities that actually cause breaches. If you have complex business logic, compliance requirements, or handle sensitive data, add a pentest after fixing automated findings.

Run a free VAS scan first. Fix those issues. Then decide if the remaining risk justifies a $10k+ pentest. For 90% of Railway apps, automated scanning is sufficient.

Skip the $10k Quote

See what a pentest would find in your Railway app. Free scan, instant results.

Start Free Security Scan

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a pentest for a Railway app cost?

Professional penetration testing typically costs $5,000-$50,000+ depending on scope. For a standard Railway web application, expect $10,000-$20,000 for a thorough assessment. VAS provides automated scanning that catches the most common vulnerabilities for free.

Can automated scans replace pentests for Railway apps?

For most Railway applications, automated scanning catches 80%+ of real vulnerabilities at a fraction of the cost. Pentests add value for complex business logic, but the majority of vibe-coded apps have standard vulnerability patterns that automated tools detect perfectly.

What vulnerabilities would a pentest find that VAS wouldn't?

Pentests excel at: complex business logic flaws, chained attack scenarios, social engineering vectors, and novel/zero-day vulnerabilities. However, these represent a small percentage of actual breaches. Most Railway app compromises come from basic misconfigurations that automated scans catch.

Should I get a pentest before launching my Railway app?

Start with automated scanning (free, instant results). Fix those issues first. If you're handling sensitive data, have compliance requirements, or have complex custom logic, then consider a pentest. For most MVPs and early-stage apps, automated scanning provides sufficient security validation.

How often should I scan vs pentest my Railway app?

Scan after every major deployment (VAS makes this easy). Pentest annually if you have the budget, or before major launches/funding rounds. The continuous automated scanning catches regressions; annual pentests provide deep-dive assurance.

Related Railway Security Resources

Railway SecurityIs Railway Safe?Railway Security ChecklistHow to Secure Railway

Last updated: January 16, 2026